Gary 的个人资料GarysBlog照片日志列表 工具 帮助
3月26日

Betrayed...

Photo by James Nachtwey

Excellent article in this month's New Yorker magazine by George Packer entitled "Betrayed:  The Iraqis who trusted America the most"
The irony is that these people are the very ones which you hear all of the supporters of the war will focus on and they are the ones who at the end of the day have the highest risk, the most fatalities and the least supported and forgotten.

Millions of Iraqis, spanning the country’s religious and ethnic spectrum, welcomed the overthrow of Saddam Hussein. But the mostly young men and women who embraced America’s project so enthusiastically that they were prepared to risk their lives for it may constitute Iraq’s smallest minority. I came across them in every city: the young man in Mosul who loved Metallica and signed up to be a translator at a U.S. Army base; the DVD salesman in Najaf whose plans to study medicine were crushed by Baath Party favoritism, and who offered his services to the first American Humvee that entered his city.

The arc from hope to betrayal that traverses the Iraq war is nowhere more vivid than in the lives of these Iraqis. America’s failure to understand, trust, and protect its closest friends in Iraq is a small drama that contains the larger history of defeat.

The photo above taken by James Nachtwey is of an Iraqi interpreter who must wear a mask to conceal his identity while he assists a soldier delivering an invitation to an Imam for a meeting with an American colonel.

评论 (2)

请稍候...
很抱歉,您输入的评论太长。请缩短您的评论。
您没有输入任何内容,请重试。
很抱歉,我们当前无法添加您的评论。请稍后重试。
若要添加评论,需要您的家长授予您相应权限。请求权限
您的家长禁用了评论功能。
很抱歉,我们当前无法删除您的评论。请稍后重试。
您已超过了一天之内允许提供的评论数上限。请在 24 小时后重试。
因为我们的系统表明您可能在向其他用户提供垃圾评论,您的帐户已禁用了评论功能。如果您认为我们错误地禁用了您的帐户,请联系 Windows Live 支持部门
完成下面的安全检查,您提供评论的过程才能完成。
您在安全检查中键入的字符必须与图片或音频中的字符一致。

若要添加评论,请使用您的 Windows Live ID 登录(如果您使用过 Hotmail、Messenger 或 Xbox LIVE,您就拥有 Windows Live ID)。登录


还没有 Windows Live ID 吗?请注册

KrallGary发表:
I'm not sure how your comments are related to the article itself.  The article specifically dealt with the fact that US Forces and support staff rely on Iraqi's to handle alot of administrative duties and in particuar translation services.  The article does an excellent job exploring how the US failed to support the very people who were supporting us and how the support they offered us was done at a terrible risk to them and their family and even today not much is being done.
 
Not sure how more boots on the ground or pulling troops out is related to this.  Under either situation the problem, given the way this administration has managed the war, would still be there.  Which is what the author is pointing out.
 
There are many betrayal's - this is one of many.
3 月 27 日
匿名 的图片
Jim 发表:
Which is the greater betrayal - not having enough boot on the ground at the start of the war, or pulling those troops out before the job is done?
3 月 26 日

引用通告

引用此项的网络日志